Multimodal Approaches to Minimizing Side Effects
As more complex procedures are performed with minimally invasive
surgical approaches (e.g., laparoscopic adrenalectomy and nephrectomy, arthroscopic
knee and shoulder reconstructions), the ability to effectively control postoperative
side effects may make the difference between performing a given procedure on an inpatient
or ambulatory basis. The introduction of multimodal approaches to perioperative
care has led to improved surgical outcomes.[525]
For routine antiemetic prophylaxis, the most cost-effective combination consists
of low-dose droperidol (0.5 to 1 mg) and dexamethasone (4 to 8 mg).[179]
Interestingly, dexamethasone appears to facilitate earlier discharge independent
of its effects on PONV.
TABLE 68-14 -- Recovery profiles and postoperative side effects of three different maintenance
anesthetic techniques for gynecologic laparoscopic surgery
|
Propofol |
Sevoflurane |
Desflurane |
Age (yr) |
29 ± 7 |
30 ± 7 |
31 ± 8 |
Weight (kg) |
69 ± 11 |
70 ± 11 |
71 ± 13 |
Aldrete score of 10 (min) |
21 ± 14 |
13 ± 5
*
|
12 ± 6
*
|
Awakening time (min) |
8 ± 4 |
5 ± 3
*
|
5 ± 4
*
|
Orientation time (min) |
13 ± 6 |
9 ± 4
*
|
9 ± 5
*
|
Fast-track eligibility [n (%)] |
7 (41) |
13 (77)
*
|
16 (94)
*
|
Actually fast-tracked [n (%)] |
6 (35) |
9 (53) |
8 (47) |
Postoperative side effects |
|
|
|
Nausea/ vomiting (%) |
0/0 |
6/0 |
18/6 |
Pain [n (%)] |
13 (77) |
11 (65) |
7 (41)
*
|
Time to home readiness (min) |
131 ± 48 |
116 ± 13 |
114 ± 51 |
Patient satisfaction (1–100) |
94 ± 7 |
93 ± 10 |
92 ± 9 |
From Coloma M, Zhou T, White PF, Forestner JE: Fast-tracking
after outpatient laparoscopy: Reasons for failure after propofol, sevoflurane and
desflurane anesthesia. Anesth Analg 93:112, 2001. |
*P
< .05; significantly different from the propofol group.
Outpatients at the highest risk of PONV will benefit from the addition of a 5-HT3
antagonist (e.g., ondansetron, dolasetron, granisetron)[173]
[179]
or an acustimulation device (e.g., SeaBand,
ReliefBand).[191]
[192]
Droperidol remains the most cost-effective antiemetic.[172]
[526]
Although controversy exists regarding its
potential for cardiac arrhythmias, droperidol has remained a safe and effective antiemetic
for over 30 years.[153]
[527]
An aggressive multimodal approach to minimize PONV can improve the recovery process
and enhance patient satisfaction.[151]
In addition
to using combination antiemetic therapy, simply ensuring adequate hydration will
minimize nausea and other side effects (e.g., dizziness, drowsiness, thirst) during
the postoperative period.[528]
*P
< 0.05 vs propofol.
A multimodal (or "balanced") approach to providing postoperative
analgesia is also essential in the ambulatory setting.[5]
[41]
[529]
Not
surprisingly,
pain has been found to be a major factor complicating recovery and delaying discharge
after ambulatory surgery.[260]
The addition of
low-dose ketamine (75 to 150 µg/kg) to a multimodal analgesic regimen improved
postoperative analgesia and functional outcome after painful orthopedic surgery procedures.
[253]
[274]
[444]
[530]
Acetazolamide (5 mg/kg IV) reduces referred
pain after laparoscopic surgery with CO2
insufflation.[531]
In addition, when compared with the conventional CO2
technique, reduced
pain and shorter convalescence were achieved after minilaparoscopic cholecystectomy
simply by using a gasless technique.[35]
The use
of nitrous oxide for pneumoperitoneum was also associated with less postoperative
pain than the standard CO2
technique was.[532]
After outpatient surgery, pain must be controllable with oral
analgesics (e.g., acetaminophen, ibuprofen, acetaminophen with codeine) before patients
are discharged from the facility. Although the potent rapid-acting opioid analgesics
(e.g., fentanyl, sufentanil) are commonly used to treat moderate to severe pain in
the early recovery period, these compounds increase the incidence of PONV and may
contribute to delayed discharge after ambulatory surgery.[127]
[260]
As a result of the concern regarding opioid-related
side effects, interest has increasingly focused on the use of potent NSAIDs (e.g.,
diclofenac, ketorolac), which can effectively reduce the requirements for opioid-containing
oral analgesics after ambulatory surgery and lead to earlier discharge home.[533]
Other less expensive oral nonsteroidal analgesics (e.g., ibuprofen, naproxen)[534]
[535]
may be acceptable alternatives to fentanyl
and the parenteral nonselective NSAIDs if administered in a preemptive fashion.
Recently, premedication with the COX-2 inhibitors (e.g., celecoxib, rofecoxib, valdecoxib,
parecoxib) has become more popular because they are devoid of potential adverse effects
on platelet function.[123]
TABLE 68-16 -- Analgesic efficacy of premedication with rofecoxib (50 mg PO) in the ambulatory
setting
|
Placebo |
Rofecoxib |
Surgery time (min) |
63 ± 29 |
66 ± 36 |
Anesthesia time (min) |
87 ± 29 |
91 ± 36 |
PACU fentanyl dose (µg) |
101 ± 133 |
22 ± 42
*
|
Max. pain score (0–10) |
6 ± 3 |
3 ± 3
*
|
Pain after discharge (0–10) |
6 ± 3 |
1 ± 1
*
|
Moderate to severe pain (%) |
58 |
16
*
|
No pain at discharge (%) |
5 |
42
*
|
Recovery times (min) |
|
|
Phase I (PACU) |
70 ± 26 |
64 ± 18 |
Phase II (DSU) |
194 ± 263 |
96 ± 43 |
Patient satisfaction (1–100) |
73 ± 19 |
98 ± 4
*
|
Completely satisfied with pain management (%) |
6 |
69 |
Quality of recovery (1–100) |
77 ± 16 |
95 ± 7
*
|
Oral analgesics postdischarge (n) |
5 ± 3 |
0.5 ± 1
*
|
DSU, day-surgery unit; PACU, postanesthesia care unit. |
From Issioui T, Klein KW, White PF, et al: Cost-efficacy
of rofecoxib vs acetaminophen for preventing pain after ambulatory surgery. Anesthesiology
97:931, 2002. |
*P
< 0.05 versus placebo group.
For routine clinical use, oral premedication with rofecoxib (50 mg), celecoxib (400
mg), or valdecoxib (40 mg) is a simple and cost-effective approach to improving pain
control and decreasing discharge times after ambulatory surgery ( Table
68-16
).[128]
[132]
[536]
The injectable COX-2 inhibitor parecoxib
may
prove useful in the future.[134]
[537]
Finally, acetaminophen is a cost-effective alternative to the traditional NSAIDs
if an effective dose (40 to 60 mg/kg orally or rectally) can be given before the
end of surgery.[538]
[539]
[540]
One of the keys to facilitating the recovery process is the routine
use of local anesthetics as part of a multimodal regimen.[127]
The use of local anesthetics for perioperative analgesia during MAC, as well as
adjuncts to general and regional anesthesia, can provide excellent analgesia during
the early recovery and postdischarge periods.[480]
[492]
[493]
Even
simple wound infiltration and instillation techniques have been shown to improve
postoperative analgesia after a variety of lower abdominal, peripheral extremity,
and even laparoscopic procedures. A wide array of peripheral extremity blocks have
also been used to minimize postoperative pain.[393]
[541]
More recently, the use of continuous local
anesthetic delivery systems has been found to improve pain control after major ambulatory
orthopedic surgery by extending peripheral nerve blocks.[395]
[397]
[398]
Patient-controlled
local anesthetic delivery has also been described for improving pain relief after
discharge home.[402]
[542]
For laparoscopic procedures, abdominal pain can also be minimized
by the use of a local anesthetic at the portals and topical application at the surgical
site. Shoulder pain is also common after laparoscopic surgery, and this pain has
been reported to be reduced with subdiaphragmatic instillation of local anesthetic
solutions.[543]
After arthroscopic knee surgery,
instillation of 30 mL of 0.5% bupivacaine into the joint space reduces postoperative
opiate requirements and permits earlier ambulation and discharge.[544]
The addition of morphine (1 to 2 mg), ketorolac (15 to 30 mg), clonidine (0.1 to
0.2 mg), and/or triamcinolone (10 to 20 mg) to the intra-articular local anesthetic
solution can further reduce pain after arthroscopic surgery.[545]
[546]
[547]
[548]
Finally, simple electroanalgesic techniques (e.g., transcutaneous or percutaneous
electrical nerve stimulation) can also be used as part of a multimodal treatment
regimen.[549]
Future growth in the complexity of
surgical procedures being performed on an ambulatory basis will require further improvements
in our ability to provide effective postoperative pain relief outside the surgical
facility.
|