GENETICS
Mutations in RYR1 occur in at
least 50% of susceptible subjects and almost all families with central core disease
(CCD). More than 30 missense mutations[24]
and
one deletion[25]
have been associated with a positive
contracture test (CHCT or IVCT) result or clinical MH, or both. Genetic heterogeneity
in MH is documented by five other loci (17q21-24, 1q32, 3q13, 7q21-24, and 5 p),
designated as malignant hyperthermia susceptibility (MHS) 2 through 6, respectively.
The only known gene other than RYR1 is the one coding
for the α1S
-subunit of DHPR, CACNL1A3,
in MHS3. Two causative mutations in this gene are linked to less than 1% of MHS
families worldwide.[26]
For practical purposes,
the RYR1 gene remains the target for genetic analysis.
Distribution of RYR1
Mutations
Multiple mutations that segregate with MHS are dispersed throughout
the RYR1 gene, and many silent polymorphisms are
present in the coding region.[27]
Some of these
have been found in patients with CCD, and in others, the RYR1
mutation is associated with CCD and MH phenotypes ( Fig.
29-3
). All reported mutations lead to an amino acid change or, in one
case, a deletion, and all are putatively functional.[24]
[25]
Until recently, it was thought that most RYR1
mutations were clustered between amino acid residues 35 and 614 (MH/CCD region 1)
and amino acid residues 2163 and 2458 (MH/CCD region 2) in the myoplasmic foot region
of the protein, but a third hotspot is in the carboxyl-terminal transmembrane loop
of the receptor, where MHS/CCD region 3 mutations may cluster.[28]
The first mutation found in this region (Ile4898Thr) was identified in a large Mexican
family with a severe and highly penetrant form of CCD, but no evidence of clinical
MH was found despite exposure of 18 members to triggering anesthetics. Subsequently,
14 more mutations associated with CCD have been identified in this region, but many
are private, found only in the index case and his or her family. However, mutations
causing MH exist in this region. In one large Maori family, the mutation Thr4826Ile
was found in five probands who experienced clinical episodes of MH and in 130 members
diagnosed by IVCT.[29]
Regional differences in the frequencies of common MHS mutations
are observed across Europe. The G341R mutation ( Table
29-1
) is present in about 6% of Irish, English, and French families but
is rare in Northern Europe. The Arg614Cys mutation is more common in German families
but less frequent in other European families. G2434R, the most prevalent mutation
in the United Kingdom, accounting for 17.5% of MHS families, has a low frequency
in continental Europe.[26]
Frequencies of RYR1
gene mutations detected in North Americans vary significantly from those found in
Europe.[25]
The Arg614Cys and Val2168Met mutations,
common in Germany and
Figure 29-3
Ryanodine receptor 1 gene (RYR1)
structure and mutational hot spots. Amino- and carboxyl-terminal domains are indicated
as NH2
and COOH, respectively. Myoplasmic and transmembrane domains are
shown at the bottom and arrows indicate dihydropyridine
receptor (DHPR) and calmodulin binding sites. Red boxes indicate mutational hot
spots with amino acid numbers below. The ovals above represent mutations associated
with malignant hyperthermia (gray), central core disease (black), or both (red).
(Courtesy of N. Sambuughin, Barrow Neurological Institute, Phoenix, AZ.)
TABLE 29-1 -- Findings of the North American malignant hyperthermia mutation panel, 2002
Exon |
Mutation
*
|
RYR1 Amino Acid Change |
No. of Families in North America
†
|
Estimated Incidence in Europe |
Phenotype |
6 |
C487T |
R163C |
2 |
2–7% |
MHS, CCD |
9 |
G742A |
G248R |
2 (1+1) |
2% |
MHS |
11 |
G1021A |
G341R |
1 |
6–17% |
MHS |
17 |
C1840T |
R614C |
6 (4+2) |
4–45% |
MHS |
39 |
C6487T |
R2163C |
2 |
4% |
MHS |
39 |
G6488A |
R2163H |
0 |
1% |
MHS, CCD |
39 |
G6502A |
V2168M |
1 |
8% |
MHS, CCD |
40 |
C6617T |
T2206M |
2 |
One family |
MHS |
44 |
Deletion |
ΔG2347 |
2 |
0% |
MHS |
44 |
G7048A |
A2350T |
1 |
0% |
MHS |
45 |
G7303A |
G2434R |
9 (5+4) |
4–10% |
MHS |
45 |
G7307T |
R2435H |
1 |
2.5% |
MHS, CCD |
46 |
G7361A |
R2454H |
4 |
One family |
MHS |
46 |
C7372 |
R2458C |
0 |
4% |
MHS |
46 |
G7373A |
R2458H |
0 |
4% |
MHS |
101 |
G14582A |
A4861H |
0 |
Multiple families |
CCD |
102 |
T14693C |
I4898T |
0 |
Multiple families |
MHS, CCD |
CCD, central core disease; MHS, malignant hyperthermia susceptibility. |
*Criteria
for the 17 mutations: (1) they occur in more than one family in North America or
Europe, and (2) previously tested sequence variant shows that it is not a polymorphism.
†Data
collaboration of the Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, Thomas
Jefferson University, Wake Forest University, University of California, Davis, and
Barrow Neurological Institute, + indicates those also found in Canada (e.g., for
exon 45, four families with the mutation G2434R were found in Canada).
Switzerland, are rare in North America. Moreover, the G341Arg mutation, common in
Ireland, England, and France, was not detected in the first 73 North American MH-susceptible
patients screened for causative mutations. The mutation common to Europe and North
America is G2434Arg, occurring in 4% to 7% of European and 5.5% of North American
families. Overall, the mutations identified in North Americans accounted for 22%
of the screened population, similar to studies in Germany and Italy.[25]
In Europe, IVCT data and RYR1 mutations correlate
well for the response to caffeine but not to halothane. In North America, all patients
identified with a causative RYR1 mutation were highly
positive for the halothane response in the CHCT, but less so for caffeine. This
variation may be caused by differences in the method of delivery and the concentration
of halothane used in the IVCT and CHCT (see "Evaluation of Susceptibility"). Genetic
screening in European and North American studies targeted only regions 1 and 2, the
original two hot spots in the gene, accounting for about one fourth of the coding
region of the RYR1 gene. The absence of RYR1
mutations in the rest of the screened population may be explained by mutations located
outside these two regions or by involvement of other genes.