MORTALITY RELATED TO ANESTHESIA
The first report of the delivery of anesthesia (ether) for an
operative procedure was in 1846. Only 2 years later, there was a report of a death
attributable to anesthesia.[41]
In that report,
Hannah Greener died on induction with chloroform. Since that time, there have been
numerous investigations into the cause of anesthesia-related death. The first formal
investigation of anesthesia-related deaths was published by John Snow in 1858.[42]
Snow analyzed 50 cases of death during chloroform anesthesia. At that time, mortality
occurred principally in healthy patients undergoing minor procedures, suggesting
that anesthesia was the principal cause of mortality. Subsequent studies reported
deaths of patients with significant comorbidities undergoing major surgical procedures;
in these cases, the cause of mortality was frequently multifactorial.
Surgery without Anesthesia
Surgical procedures were carried out before the introduction of
anesthetics. The key to success was the speed of the procedure, with successful
amputations lasting only 30 seconds. Strong assistants and restraints were frequently
required. Alternatively, decreased cerebral perfusion by means of bilateral carotid
compression was used to decrease sensation during the procedure. Surgical procedures
were associated with significant risk of death and, at a minimum, were associated
with severe pain. The development of anesthesia has been heralded as one of the
great advances of modern medicine because it allowed surgery to advance.
TABLE 24-3 -- Estimates of the incidence of mortality related to anesthesia before 1980
Study |
Year |
Number of Anesthetics |
Primary Cause |
Primary and Associated Cause |
Beecher and Todd[21]
|
1954 |
599,548 |
1:2680 |
1:1560 |
Dornette and Orth[43]
|
1956 |
63,105 |
1:2427 |
1:1343 |
Schapira et al.[44]
|
1960 |
22,177 |
1:1232 |
1:821 |
Phillips et al.[45]
|
1960 |
— |
1:7692 |
1:2500 |
Dripps et al.[46]
|
1961 |
33,224 |
1:852 |
1:415 |
Clifton and Hotton[47]
|
1963 |
205,640 |
1:6048 |
1:3955 |
Memery[48]
|
1965 |
114,866 |
1:3145 |
1:1082 |
Gebbie[49]
|
1966 |
129,336 |
— |
1:6158 |
Minuck[50]
|
1967 |
121,786 |
1:6766 |
1:3291 |
Marx et al.[35]
|
1973 |
34,145 |
— |
1:1265 |
Bodlander[52]
|
1975 |
211,130 |
1:14,075 |
1:1703 |
Harrison[51]
|
1978 |
240,483 |
— |
1:4537 |
Hovi-Viander[53]
|
1980 |
338,934 |
1:5059 |
1:1412 |
From Ross AF, Tinker JH: Anesthesia risk. In
Miller RD (ed): Anesthesia, 3rd ed. New York, Churchill Livingstone, 1990. |