Previous Next

Discussion Groups

A popular means of professional communication on the Internet is known as a discussion group. In essence, groups of interested people provide their e-mail addresses to a central site known as a host or listserver, thereby creating a list of members or recipients. A member of that list may then send an e-mail message to the central host, which in turn rebroadcasts the message to all members on the list. The message traffic on these lists may be very light or dozens of messages per day. Many active discussion groups provide a once-per-day digest service as an alternative to receiving a daily swarm of individual messages. The content of the messages ranges from seeking and rendering clinical advice, to discussion of cases, to even frank commercial "spam." Some listservers are "moderated," which means that the person owning the list reviews each incoming message for appropriateness before rebroadcasting it. The largest anesthesia-related discussion Group at present is the GASNet Anesthesiology Discussion Group (http://gasnet.med.yale.edu/anesthesiology/index.php). A list of over 50 anesthesia-related groups with contact addresses can be obtained at http://www.eur.nl/cgi-bin/wrt4.pl.

An Internet service known as USENET provides an alternative variant of the discussion group. Instead of using e-mail to communicate with a fixed list of subscribers, USENET follows a public bulletin board model. USENET provides for topical bulletin boards, also known as newsgroups, to which anyone may read or post messages. At present, USENET contains over 50,000 separate newsgroups, although at the moment no publicly accessible group is related specifically to the practice of anesthesia or critical care. Newsgroups are named to place themselves within a subject hierarchy. For example, "comp.sys.mac.digest" is a newsgroup within the root group concerning computers (comp) related to Macintosh computers (.sys.mac) that specifically contains summaries of news, commentary, and new file postings (.digest). Another example is "rec.auto.bmw," which is a newsgroup where hobbyists and enthusiasts (rec = recreation) discuss the minutiae of BMW automobiles. Topics of general medical interest may be found within the sci.med (medical sciences) hierarchy, for example, sci.med, sci.med.cardiology, sci.med.pharmacy, sci.med.informantics. Basic neuroscience is also covered in the bionet.neurosci group. The uneven quality of information within discussion groups and newsgroups requires a philosophy of caveat lector on the part of their users.

The power as well as failing of the Internet is that it provides an accessible medium where true freedom of the press is the rule. Medical professionals and health care consumers may enjoy the adventure of surfing the web as much as anyone, but when seeking reliable medical information, it is prudent to exercise judgment and rely on sources of known provenance.

Previous Next