NON-HEART-BEATING ORGAN DONORS
A relatively recent development to increase the organ supply is
the use of non-heart-beating organ donors. Originally introduced in the sixties,
it was subsequently abandoned and has only recently been reintroduced. Medical centers
re-explored this source of potential donors for abdominal organs (mainly kidneys).
[21]
In the United States, the use of organs from
non-heart-beating donors steadily increased over the past decade, albeit at an overall
low level. In 1993, the number of non-heart-beating organ donors was 42; it increased
to 167 by 2001.[22]
Policies were developed by
organ procurement officials and hospitals to allow organ donation as an option to
be considered by relatives of patients who potentially qualify as non-heart-beating
organ donors. Unlike brain-dead donors, whose heart function, circulation, and tissue
oxygenation are preserved until the organs are retrieved, organs from non-heart-beating
donors can be removed only after cardiac arrest. The difference invariably introduces
a more significant warm ischemia time that can potentially result in suboptimal donor
organs. Non-heart-beating donors can be categorized as controlled or uncontrolled,
and these categories determine the extent of warm ischemia experienced by the organ
donors. Controlled non-heart-beating donors are those for whom the transplant team
is awaiting the cardiac arrest and all necessary preparations for rapid organ harvest
are in place. In contrast, uncontrolled non-heart-beating donors are those who have
suffered unanticipated cardiac
arrest; resuscitation has been unsuccessful and consideration is then being given
to possible organ donation. It is evident that in addition to a prolonged warm ischemia
time, legal, ethical, and logistic concerns prevent many centers from adopting this
form of organ donation.[23]
However, recent studies
from Switzerland and the United States have demonstrated favorable long-term results
with regard to graft function in recipients of organs from non-heart-beating donors.
[24]
[25]
[26]
It remains to be seen whether this form of organ procurement from non-heart-beating
donors will achieve widespread acceptance in the transplant community and provide
a means to significantly increase the donor organ pool.